Many scientists dream of a career in academia. Despite this, a large proportion of researchers leave academia early in their careers. Photo credit: ThisisEngineering via Unsplash
Early career scientists include PhD candidates and postdoctoral scientists (postdocs). Moreover, they refer to a group of people from various walks of life united by a great interest in scientific research and a desire to expand the bounds of scientific knowledge. It is a stage every scientist must go through if they wish to have a permanent position, largely seen as the end goal for a career in research. However, a 2024 study tracking around 150,000 scientists from 2000 showed that roughly one-third of scientists leave science within five years of their first paper, and around half leave after ten years. Why do such a large proportion of scientists give up on their dreams of pursuing academia? How should universities and governments react to this trend?
The 2024 National Centre for Science and Engineering Statistics report quantifies the harsh reality of what early career scientists sign up for. For example, a PhD graduate in the life and physical sciences can expect to earn roughly double their salary if they go into industry instead of taking a postdoc in the United States. Considering elite academic institutions also tend to be located in expensive cities, being in industry, where you are greatly alleviated of financial concerns and are still able to do science (albeit with less autonomy) is an enticing alternative, especially if you have to take care of family.
Elite academic institutions also tend to be located in expensive cities.
Postdocs are not only poorly paid but also lack job security. Most postdoctoral fellowships are based on grants that last two to three years. Outlook on working as a postdoc is echoed in Nature’s 2023 survey of principal investigators, where 44% of respondents agreed that they were struggling to recruit postdocs, and 81% agreed that ‘a lack of career stability leading postdocs down other career paths’ was partly to blame.
But do scientists have autonomy over their research in academia? This question points to another widespread issue, colloquially referred to as the “publish or perish” culture. Career progression in academia is mainly dependent on publishing in prestigious journals and receiving prestigious grants. These journals are owned by for-profit companies whose primary interests are to publish papers that will receive attention. Along the same line, these grants fund projects that are representative of the current interests of the scientific community, especially those with direct translational impact. Although conducting research in academia compared to industry may give you relatively more autonomy, it may not be enough to accept all the other downsides of choosing the former.
The lack of autonomy is not the only problem associated with the “publish or perish” culture. It also incentivises scientists to partake in politics that are unrelated to, and take time and energy away from, scientific discovery. These include putting in irrelevant or unnecessary references, being pressured to include senior researchers as authors despite their contributing very little to the paper, and dividing a big project into numerous different papers to get more publications. Some even argue that such politics are to blame for why there are fewer disruptive and groundbreaking publications in science over time. Altogether, one may feel that the current business model for scientific publication does not have greater scientific progress as its priority. Altogether, one may feel that the current business model for scientific publication does not have greater scientific progress as its priority.
The lack of autonomy is not the only problem associated with the “publish or perish” culture. It also incentivises scientists to partake in politics that are unrelated to, and take time and energy away from, scientific discovery.
The final point may be more applicable to early career scientists from institutions with more lay prestige and is certainly a consideration for Oxford students. It relates to the “career funnel” that exists from these top institutions to elite professional service careers, namely finance and management consulting. These firms often recruit PhD candidates for their technical abilities or analytical skills, offering huge increases to their original salary. The stigma in academia associated with people entering such careers is also a well-documented phenomenon, which views them as “selling out” to corporate wealth over “pure” intellectual pursuit. This tension is reflected in popular culture. For example, Real Genius (1985), a comedy about gifted university students whose scientific research is appropriated by their professor for a military project, explores the conflict between intellectual curiosity and the commercial or institutional interests that can shape scientific research. Although not directly about scientists leaving academia for corporate careers, it illustrates the broader cultural unease surrounding the relationship between scientific pursuits and profit-driven interests.
The high attrition rate for early career scientists in academia is a multifaceted issue, and the factors listed here are far from exhaustive. Although more reasons are discussed in the media (e.g., long hours, workplace toxicity, COVID, and hypercompetition), I focused on those that are more unique to academia than other jobs an early career scientist would consider. I now turn to what must, if anything, be done by universities and governments in response. by universities and governments in response.
Firstly, an effort needs to be made to make working as a postdoc more attractive. As of now, early career scientists take up postdocs to pursue science despite, not because of, their working conditions. A 2023 survey of postdocs in Dutch universities showed that about 40% of the respondents reported ‘serious problems concerning their mental health’. Morally, governments and universities should not take advantage of such individuals and their passion for science, who would still choose to contribute to humanity through scientific discovery. Indeed, early career scientists have spoken up, with postdocs in the US going on strike demanding higher wages.
One suggested method for universities to improve postdoc job satisfaction has been redeployment, which refers to prioritising existing postdocs for applications to internal vacancies when their contracts end. Redeployment is at odds with picking the most suitable candidate for the job, however, as required skillsets might be highly specific. This goes against the interests of principal investigators who want the best candidates and requires additional resources to be spent on training. This goes against the interests of principal investigators who want the best candidates and requires additional resources to be spent on training.
Instead of treating early career scientists as a perpetual, floating workforce, universities could reconsider the structural hierarchy of academic research. One highly advocated alternative is the creation of permanent staff scientist roles. These are full-time employees dedicated purely to conducting research or managing complex methodologies, decoupled from the rigid tenure-track pipeline. While this offers much-needed job security and retains invaluable technical expertise, it is by no means a universal solution. Creating these roles does not magically generate the money to pay for them, and an overreliance on staff scientists without broader systemic change risks creating a two-tiered academic system where early career researchers are still bottlenecked from advancing to independent principal investigator positions.
Ultimately, internal university restructuring can only achieve so much without addressing the fundamental engine of the academic enterprise: grant funding. Without a stable and expanding pool of research capital, structural fixes merely shuffle a shrinking number of chairs on a sinking ship. To realistically reduce early career attrition, governments must commit to retaining and steadily increasing baseline grant funding. A robust financial pipeline relieves the hypercompetitive pressure on principal investigators, enabling universities to offer postdocs longer-term contracts, living wages, and genuine institutional stability rather than treating them as cheap, temporary labour.
Without a stable and expanding pool of research capital, structural fixes merely shuffle a shrinking number of chairs on a sinking ship.
The fragility of this ecosystem becomes painfully apparent when public funding is destabilised, as recently witnessed in the United States. During the Trump administration, sweeping funding freezes and the abrupt cancellation of thousands of active National Institutes of Health (NIH) and National Science Foundation (NSF) grants created immediate chaos across research institutions. Because postdoc salaries depend almost entirely on “soft money” from these federal grants, mid-project cancellations forced universities into sudden hiring freezes and abrupt layoffs. It highlighted a grim reality: when a nation treats science funding as a volatile political football, the precarity of the postdoc transitions from a chronic burden to an acute existential crisis.
Ultimately, if governments wish to reverse the trend of high attrition, they must treat scientific research as a vital, protected public good, ensuring that the people expanding human knowledge are not treated as disposable collateral damage in political or economic shifts.
Some ideas expressed in this article are opinion, and may not represent the opinion of The Oxford Scientist as a whole.
Edited by Nikola Kalita, Leah Belson, and Mia Clark-Webb
